One common source of controversy in practice management is the proper way to handle unintentional overpayments by clients. For an explanation of the issue, we asked Judith Equels of The Florida Bar’s Law Office Management Assistance Service and Elizabeth Tarbert, Ethics Counsel for The Florida Bar, to discuss the mistakes that lawyers make in handling such overpayments and to offer us their recommendations for best practices in this area.
The following series of questions and answers summarizes their responses:
Q. When a lawyer receives unearned fees from a client, does it make a difference how those fees are characterized?
A: Most definitely. If the attorney and client have not agreed in writing that the payment is non-refundable, the payment of unearned fees is refundable, must be deposited and held in the trust account until earned by the lawyer.
Q: What is the difference between a true retainer and a deposit against future fees?
A: A deposit against future fees (“evergreen retainer,” for example) is just that – money given to the lawyer to apply against fees that will be charged to the case/matter in the future. This money has not yet been earned, and must be held in the trust account. A deposit against future fees is not the same as a true retainer. The following is an excerpt from TFB E.O. 93-2:
In essence, a “true retainer” is akin to an option contract: the client pays the attorney a fee for the right to employ the attorney. The “true retainer” is therefore earned upon receipt and should not be deposited in the trust account.
Q: Can a lawyer deposit a true retainer into the lawyer’s trust account?
A: No. See answer above.
Q: Must a lawyer deposit an advance against future fees into the lawyer’s trust account?
A: Yes. An advance against future fees is not yet earned; unearned fees are always held in the trust account.
Q: If the lawyer has the client’s consent, can the lawyer treat that advance as earned income and place it in the lawyer’s operating account?
A: The lawyer and the client must agree in writing that the advance payment is non-refundable, and assuming the fee is reasonable, the lawyer may then deposit the fee portion into the operating account. However, if any portion of the advance payment (now the agreed-upon non-refundable payment) represents costs, that portion (earmarked for costs) must be held in the trust account until disbursed for the purposes intended. If the client writes one check to the lawyer representing both the non-refundable fee and costs, the lawyer must deposit the entire amount into trust, then when the check clears withdraw the portion representing the nonrefundable fee, leaving the portion for costs in trust until disbursed as costs as agreed by the client.
Q: When a client makes an erroneous overpayment, how should the attorney handle the situation?
A: It depends. First, call the client and make certain the money received is an erroneous overpayment and not an intended advance payment. Confirm the response in writing.
If the client instructs the attorney to treat the money as an advance against future fees, the money should be deposited into the lawyer’s trust account.
If in fact the money is an erroneous overpayment:
(1) and the entire check is an overpayment, return the check with the signature line torn off, accompanied by a cover letter.
(2) and part of the client’s payment by check is an erroneous overpayment, deposit the entire amount into trust because part of the check represents client funds that the lawyer has no entitlement to and client funds must always be held in trust. The lawyer should then remove the portion that represents the lawyer’s earned fee from the trust account and deposit it in the lawyer’s operating account and disburse the erroneously overpaid amount out of the trust account to the client. The lawyer should never agree to refund the erroneous overpayment to anyone other than the maker of the check/overpayment in question.
(3) and, if the erroneous overpayment is by wire transfer, ask the bank to reverse the wire. If the bank cannot do this, make sure you have the wire transfer Fed reference number, and confirmation that the wire has actually cleared the bank, then cut an operating check for the overpayment and mail with a cover letter. Beware of unscrupulous clients. If the client does not answer the lawyer’s inquiry, or asks the lawyer to “sit” on the money for a while, but does not want the money to be considered a “true” or “conflict” retainer, the lawyer may be unwittingly helping the unscrupulous client hide money. There must always be a valid (legal work – case or matter-related) reason for holding money in trust for a client or third party.
Q: Are there any other considerations that affect the handling of unearned fees?
A: As stated above, unearned fees must be held in the trust account. Lawyers always should execute a signed fee contract and/or letter of representation with the client that clearly defines the scope of the work to be performed, why money is being held in trust, and how and when it will be disbursed. In addition to the signed representation agreement, it is considered a best practice to notify the client in writing (giving the client a reasonable time period to respond) before drawing down on the advance fee payment once it is earned.
Filed under: Ethics/Professionalism, The Practical Practice by Kevin Johnson Wednesday, August 4th, 2010
Comments Off